An article in the Wiltshire Archaeological and Natural History Magazine of 1920 summarised Roman finds near Purton, Wiltshire. It mentions the discovery of a probable Roman villa in Victorian times but then goes on to say “This find is not to be connected with fragments of mosaic of glass said to have been recently found at this place, which are obviously of foreign make and comparatively modern date.” So, the authors are saying that sometime after the Roman villa was abandoned somebody came along and built a house with a glass mosaic in exactly the same place; this seems highly unlikely.
Glass mosaics are known from other parts of the empire and there is a famous example in Vienne in France. There are also some examples of glass being used in mosaics much closer to home. The Corinium museum in Cirencester (about 12 miles from Purton) has several mosaics from Roman Cirencester. The hare mosaic which is displayed prominently near the entrance to the museum has glass tesserae along the back of the hare, and the seasons mosaic has glass tesserae in two different panels. The head of Flora, representing spring, has tesserae of red glass in her hair. When first discovered the tesserae were not so vibrant as the red glass had become discoloured with age but when polished the red colour was restored and the red flowers became apparent. Red glass tesserae were also used in the panel showing the hunter Actaeon being attacked by his own dogs. Actaeon had dared to gaze upon the goddess Diana as she bathed. When Diana saw Actaeon she turned him into a stag but his dogs no longer recognised him and attacked him, and this scene is depicted in the mosaic. The blood coming from Actaeon’s leg is depicted with tesserae made of red glass. Clearly there is a local tradition of using glass tesserae in mosaics in the Cirencester area so it is highly likely that the glass mosaic discovered at Purton in the early 20th century was Roman. Cirencester was home to a school of mosaicists who installed mosaics across the region so it is possible that the use of glass in mosaics was more widespread than we currently realise.
So where did these fragments of coloured glass come from? It is generally accepted that there was no primary glass manufacturing in Roman Britain. Raw glass appears to have been imported then re-melted to produce glass items. Fahy noted the correlation between ceramic production sites and glass production sites and both industries require high temperature kilns, sources of fuel and a skilled workforce. If the glass fragments were produced in Britain rather than being imported then Purton would be a possible manufacturing site. Apart from the tile manufacturing site at Minety, it is the closest kiln site to Cirencester and has a similar operational date to the mosaics being produced with glass tesserae. Anderson dated the pottery from the kiln site to the mid 2nd century and Witts says that the seasons mosaic could be dated to the late 2nd century or early third century. Cosh dates it to the 2nd century. It is certainly possible that the dates overlapped. My conclusion is that the “fragments of mosaic of glass” were part of a 2nd century mosaic installed in a Roman villa at Purton. Furthermore, the glass fragments may have been produced at the nearby kilns, only 100m from the villa site.
The siting of the kilns found at Dogridge in 1975 is unusual. Usually, kilns are located on the clay that is used to produce pottery but here the bedrock is limestone. There is a deposit of Ampthill/Kimmeridge clay about 200m to the south but there is no evidence of any clay pits in this area. There are larger deposits a bit further afield and deposits of Oxford clay on lower ground to the north and west, but if they used this clay why didn’t they put the kilns where the clay was? The location away from clay deposits suggests the kilns weren’t used for high volume production. If they had wanted high volume production they would have put the kilns closer to the source.
The Purton kilns were discovered during housebuilding. Anderson was able to inspect the kilns but was not able to conduct a proper archaeological investigation before the site was developed. He thought there could be as many as six kilns on the site and noted an unusual kiln design for kiln 1. The flue was almost as wide as the body of the oven. Anderson also noted the presence of unfired clay and potsherds. It is possible that the location of the kilns on higher ground and the wide flue were both designed to increase the airflow through the kiln and produce higher temperatures. The Romans in Purton project dug a test pit about 20 m south-east of the location of the kilns in the HER found no evidence of pottery manufacturing but did find a small piece of slag, “probably related to metalworking” so it is certainly possible that the kilns were used for metal or glass production.
The Romans in Purton project dug test pits in the gardens of volunteers in the Dogridge and Pavenhill areas. Six tesserae were found in the gardens of houses on the opposite side of Pavenhill from the Royal George pub. The tesserae appear not to be cut from fired pottery. They appear to be comparitively small and shaped before firing, with slightly concave faces as would be produce if wet clay was shaped into a cube by fingers. These smaller tesserae were most likely produced to be part of a mosaic with a pictorial design, not simply a geometric pattern. They could also have been produced in the Purton kilns.
References
Anderson, A.S. (1979) The Roman Pottery Industry in North Wiltshire. Thamesdown Borough Council
Buckman and Newmarch, C. H. (1850) Illustrations of the Remains of Roman Art in Cirencester. George Bell, London
Cosh, S. R. (2026) Mosaics in Britannia. Archaeopress, Bicester
A number of changes to agricultural practices took place towards the end of the Anglo-Saxon period. The visible remnants of these changes are the ridges and furrows of the open fields. Ridges in the fields were created by repeatedly ploughing soil into the middle of a ridge. This also created a furrow between the ridges, and the furrows were about 15m apart, with a ridge between. Each strip of ridge and furrow was owned by a household.
There were usually two or three open fields and crops were rotated around the fields and the rotation also included a year when no crops were planted in one of the fields. The fields were managed co-operatively by the families that farmed them. Villages coalesced around the manor and the church.
The problem we have is that there is very little evidence for the date of these changes. David Stocker in his English Heritage book of the landscape of the East Midlands suggests a date of around 850 based upon the evidence of pottery finds in the open fields and modern villages. Fieldwalking of fields known to be open fields produced some dense scatters of pottery from before 850. These are believed to be the remains of farmsteads that had been moved to make way for the open fields. The open fields had a thin scatter of pottery post-850 these were generally small fragments believed to have come from domestic waste used to manure the fields. Where sites in modern villages have been excavated the amount of pottery increases after about 850.
These changes were revolutionary, having a big impact on the way that people farmed and the way that they interacted with each other. They happened at around the same time across a broad swathe of the country, stretching from Yorkshire down to Dorset, although large areas of the country (Wales, Devon and Cornwall, East Anglia) were unaffected. Despite the magnitude of the changes there is very little documentary evidence for their implementation or existence. Domesday Book contains a few hints that arable farming may have happened in this way but the lack of evidence in Domesday has convinced some that the open fields and ridge and furrow farming must have been introduced after the Norman conquest.
An example of the fragmentary nature of the evidence can be found in a charter of 999 concerning land in South Cerney in south Gloucestershire. After a dispute the king granted the estate of South Cerney to the widow, Eadflaed. The charter describes the boundary of the estate and these seem to agree with the boundary of the modern parish.
The interesting bit is right at the start of the description of the boundary in the north of the parish. In modern English it reads:
Start at Cat’s stone and follow a furrow on the family moor
0n the High Street follow the road to the moot ford
The High Street is Ermine Street which runs diagonally across the top right-hand corner of the image.
At the end of the description of the bounds the charter describes how the route follows the River Churn then back to the Cat’s stone, so the furrow mentioned lies between the River Churn and Ermine Street and lies on the Estate boundary which is also the parish boundary.
The furrow referred to is likely to be the ridge and furrow that can be seen on LIDAR. The furrows align with the parish boundary. (The parish boundary is shown in red and the field with the ridge and furrow is outlined in blue)
David Stocker’s date of 850 for the creation of the open fields came from studies in Leicestershire and Northamptonshire so may not be applicable in South Gloucestershire, but we now have evidence that ridge and furrow here preceded 999.
Notes
The translation of the charter of 999 comes from “Fertile Fields and Small Settlements – A History of South Cerney and Cerney Wick” by Michael Oakeshott
The Romans invaded Britain in 43AD. They began exploiting its mineral wealth relatively quickly and they were mining lead in the Mendips (Somerset) by 49AD. A lead ingot found near Wrexham and stamped with a text recording the Emperor Nero suggests that lead was being mined in Wales by the 60s and two lead ingots found at Chester are evidence that lead mining had started in Flintshire by 74 AD. There is no direct evidence for the date of commencement of lead mining in Derbyshire but one of the named individuals on a Derbyshire ingot (a ‘pig’) of lead is also known from the Mendips and he was active there sometime between 69 and 79AD so it is likely that he was active in Derbyshire in the second half of the first century.
The Derbyshire peak district is believed to be at the southern edge of the territory of the Brigantes. Initially, the Brigantes under their leader, Cartimandua, were pro-Roman but the Brigantes expelled her and the Romans took direct control of Brigantian territory between 69 and 80 AD. The southern part of Brigantian territory was under their control in the early part of that period, so if Derbyshire followed the pattern of other lead mining districts, lead mining quickly followed the Roman occupation.
Pliny, writing around 77-79AD, said that, in Britain, lead was “found in the surface stratum of the earth in such abundance that there is a law prohibiting the production of more than a certain amount.” So, clearly lead mining was a regulated industry so there would need to be some administration and policing of the activities. The archaeological evidence for the management of the lead mining industry comes from the inscriptions on the pigs of lead. About 35% of the inscribed pigs of lead in Britain contain the abbreviation LVT. This is believed to refer to Lutudarum, a place name in the Ravenna Cosmography, which lies amongst a group of place names in Derbyshire and Cheshire. In the list it is next to Derventio, believed to be the Roman place of Little Chester in Derby. All the pigs of lead that have the abbreviation LUT are believed to originate in Derbyshire, and Lutudarum is believed to be the administrative centre of the Roman Derbyshire lead mining district.
Fig 1 Roman Pig of Lead from Yeavely in Derbyshire
Fig 2 Inscriptions mentioning LVT (Lutudarum) from Pulborough (top) and Brough on Humber (Petuaria). The top one is believed to refer to Tiberius Claudius Triferna who was also active in the Mendips between 69 and 79. The bottom one mentions the society that had some sort of role in the industry
There are 20 pigs of lead that are known to contain the abbreviation LUT. These are listed in the attached table (Appendix 3). I have sorted them into three groups:
Group 1 (12 pigs) Inscriptions begin with a named individual, then have the abbreviation LUT, an abbreviation for Britain, and the EX ARG which probably means that it is a product of the lead and silver works
Group 2 (7 pigs) Inscriptions begin with an abbreviation for a Society, followed by an abbreviation for Lutudarum, followed by an abbreviation for Britain, then EX ARG (from the lead/silver works)
Group 3 (1 pig) includes an abbreviation for the Emperor Hadrian
In the first group the rights to mine and process lead seem to have been granted to an individual. As already mentioned, one of this group, Tiberius Claudius Triferna, was also involved in lead mining in the Mendips between 69 and 79AD so this system of granting mineral rights was probably the first one operating in Derbyshire and these 12 pigs are the earliest ones found.
At some stage the mineral rights seem to have been granted to a society and the seven pigs in group 2 belong to this period.
There is one pig that mentions Hadrian that must come from the period 117 to 138. There are also two pigs with partial inscriptions.
It is difficult to imagine how these pigs of lead could have been lost. Most weigh about 180Ibs and are valuable items so if you had lost one you would have known about it. The most likely explanation is that pigs of lead were stolen, then hidden so that they could be collected at a later date. For some reason they were never retrieved.
In Group 1, three of the pigs come from the Matlock area, four are from the north bank of the Humber estuary, four are from Sussex (although three of these are now lost) and the other Nottinghamshire. The three pigs from the Matlock area are near the River Derwent but not near a known Roman road. The pigs from the Humber Estuary were found between the outflow of the Trent and the Roman fort of Petuaria. This strongly suggests that, in this earliest phase of extraction, lead was being mined in the Matlock area and floated down the Derwent and Trent to Petuaria. Some think that this indicates lead was being transported by sea from here, possibly being exported. I think it more likely that it was being transported to York by the Roman road running from Petuaria. Lead could easily be floated downstream but trying to propel a heavy load up the Ouse was more difficult than sending it by road. Lead not destined for York could also be floated down the Derwent and join the Roman road network at Little Chester. This could explain why the fort at Strutts Park nr Derby was abandoned at this time in favour of the fortified settlement of Little Chester a bit closer to the river.
In group 2, the pigs that mention a society, four were found on the Humber estuary, one was in Warwickshire and two were found in South Derbyshire (away from the lead mining area). No pigs of lead that mention the society have been found in the Derbyshire mining area. This could indicate than when the administration of the lead mining area was given to the Society Lutudarensis, security was tightened and they were able to reduce pilfering in the local area. All this group are near Roman roads – the road from Petuaria to York, Watling Street and the road from Little Chester to Rocester.
One pig mentions the emperor Hadrian (117 to 138AD). This is different to the lead mining area in the Mendips where most of the pigs found mention the emperor and enables dating up to 169AD. However, lead mining did not stop when these inscribed pigs of lead are no longer found and the lack of inscribed pigs may mean that the market ceased to be regulated, around the reign of Hadrian in Derbyshire but later in the Mendips. It is possible that Hadrian himself changed the way that lead mining in the Peak District was organised.
Fig 3 Pigs of Lead in Roman Britain. Location indicated by red dot
Fig 4 Roman Pigs of Lead in Derbyshire
So, what can we deduce about the location of Lutudarum?
It must have been a place with activity in the second half of the first century. If there is archaeology it should show 1st century occupation
It would probably be on a Roman Road
It continued as a settlement for some time and was important enough to be mentioned in the Ravenna Cosmography
It may have declined after Hadrian when the management/administration of the lead mining area changed
It need not have been a mining or smelting site, it may just have been an administrative site
Using these criteria most of the Romano-British sites listed by Lane (see appendix 2) would be ruled out as locations for Lutudarum because the available archaeological evidence shows there was no significant activity on the sites before 150AD. Carsington is not ruled out completely as there is some limited evidence for activity in the late first century. In my opinion that evidence does not support a significant 1st century settlement in that area. The archaeological evidence is summarised in Appendix 1. It is possible that there are other areas around Carsington that have earlier remains but archaeologists had four years to investigate before the reservoir was filled and no other possible sites were identified.
Wirksworth has been touted as a possible site, mainly because it became an administrative site in the Anglo-Saxon period. However, there are very few Roman finds from the area and no evidence of any Roman buildings. The Roman road that runs from Buxton to Little Chester near Derby is thought by some to run through Wirksworth but recent LIDAR analysis by David Ratledge has shown that it does not deviate far from a direct line and runs close to the Scow Brook site south of Carsington then Kirk Ireton. Additionally, recent research into lead pollution in the teeth of local people showed there wasn’t continuity in lead production. After the Roman period lead production did not restart until about 650AD so institutions could not have carried on during that period.
The area covered by Matlock, Matlock Bath and Cromford is similar to Wirksworth – there is a scattering of Roman finds but no evidence of any Roman buildings and there are no known Roman roads in the area. A distribution map of pigs of lead found in the area shows that the pigs of lead were found close to the River Derwent and this could have been used to transport pigs of lead downstream to Little Chester where they were able to join the Roman road network or carry on down the Trent to the Humber estuary. Lane believed that the Derwent could have been navigable for small vessels in the Roman period. The inscribed pigs of lead from this area were all from the earliest phase of lead production so it is possible that Lutudarum is still to be found in this area. My guess is that the most suitable location would be somewhere around Cromford where all the traffic coming from the lead mining area could be monitored.
There is another possibility. Derventio has been accepted as the Roman name of Little Chester but the evidence is a little thin. Perhaps Little Chester, where lead shipments arrived on boats from the mining area, and were sorted for distribution via the Roman Road network or for further river transport to the Humber, is a better candidate for Lutudarum and Derventio is somewhere else, possibly Great Wilne. (This is highly speculative). The timing of the building of Little Chester would fit this scenario. The first Roman fort in the area was Strutt’s Park on the west side of the Derwent on raised ground so has a more commanding position. This was built around 50 AD and was used until around 80 AD. Little Chester, on the East side of the river, has a complex history but the first buildings on the site were wooden buildings, some date to between 80 and 120 AD and some date to the late first or early 2nd century. Although Little Chester is usually described as a fort there is little evidence of military activity in the first phase of occupation and the ramparts seem to be later additions, so perhaps Little Chester was built for some role in the distribution of lead; we know that lead mining in Derbyshire began around 80AD (+ or – 10 yrs)
So far, we have two serious candidates for Lutudarum – Cromford and Little Chester. There is one more – Chesterfield. Chesterfield meets all the criteria for Lutudarum.
The first sign of Roman activity is the building of the fort during the Flavian dynasty (69 – 96AD)
The fort is on a Roman road (Ryknield Street)
The fort was occupied until the middle of the third century
There hasn’t been enough archaeological investigation to determine if the usage of the fort declined after 150
Chesterfield has been rejected in the past because ‘it is too far from the lead mining district’. But we have seen that the earliest pigs of lead were found in the Matlock area and the distance from Chesterfield to Matlock is only 10 miles (by car on modern roads). It is also worth noting that when the Romans pushed northwards, Brigantia was friendly with Rome and not conquered but they may have allowed lead mining in its territory. The fort at Chesterfield would have been located outside Brigantian territory but close enough to administer lead mining activity. The separation of the mining activity and the administration centre may explain the losses and subsequent rediscovery of Roman pigs of lead experienced in the early phase of lead mining.
We now have three or four viable candidates for Lutudarum and it is unlikely that there will ever be any foolproof evidence of its location. A Roman milestone saying “Lutudarum 2 miles” 2 miles away from a known Roman place would be good evidence but if we haven’t found anything like that and it is unlikely we ever will. Six months ago I favoured Cromford as my preferred location but since then I have re-read relevant papers and secondary sources and concluded that Lutudarum is more likely to be a site with evidence of first century occupation, ie Little Chester or Chesterfield. It would be foolish to bang my fist on the table and say “Lutudarum is Chesterfield” or “Lutudarum is Little Chester”. It is more realistic to assign some probabilities to the different candidates. So, this my estimation of the chances of the different candidates being Lutudarum:
Chesterfield 40%
Little Chester 30%
Cromford 15%
Carsington 10%
Somewhere else 5%
Unfortunately we will probably never know.
Appendix 1 – Archaeological Investigations at Carsington
The Roman finds near Carsington are thought to be evidence for Lutudarum. I disagree but think it is important that all the archaeological evidence is considered, so I have summarised the evidence here.
Lomas J., (1960) A Romano-British Site at Owslow Farm, Carsington. DAJ v080 109-116
An inscribed pig of lead had been found during ploughing in 1946. National Grid Reference 238533, reported by RWP Cockerton in the Derbyshire Archaeological Journal (DAJ) LXX111 (1953) 110. A search in 1959 resulted in a concentration of sherds of coarse Romano-British pottery near to the Brassington/Carsington parish boundary. Pottery fragments date the site to the early 3rd Century. There was probably only one dwelling at the site. Many nodules of lead were found in the excavated trenches but there was no evidence of a smelting site. If there was smelting nearby it would probably happen at the top of the slope where more wind would have created a better draught and higher temperatures; unfortunately, any sites in this area would ha.ve been obliterated by later mining.
Ling R. and Courtney T. (1981) Excavations at Carsington 1979 – 80. DAJ v101 58 – 87
Two sites near the Scow Brook are now under Carsington Reservoir. When site A was being excavated the farmer drew the attention of the archaeologists to another site, about 700m to the south, now called site B. This paper looks at the excavations of site B. This was initially identified as a kiln complex and building by the surface finds. The building was rectangular and divided into rooms. Room A had a partial underfloor heating system. The building may have been built on the site of an earlier structure as tesserae, fragments of tiles and window glass were found within the fabric of the building. The finds on the site as a whole date it from the mid 2nd century to the 4th century. Although surface finds suggested tile production this was not confirmed by excavation, nor was there any evidence of lead working. The underfloor heating system and the presence of box flue tiles suggest the building was for domestic, not industrial purposes.
According to the paper on the excavations of site A (Dearne et al), the building on site B lay within a ditched enclosure which also contained other possible building platforms.
Ling, R., Hunt, C.O., Manning, W.H., Wild, F. and Wild, J. P. () Excavations at Carsington 1983-84. DAJ v110 (1990) 030-055
This paper is about further work on site B. It was designed to check the area around the building discovered in the 1979-80 excavation. It confirms occupation from the 2nd half of the 2nd century to the late 4th century. The possible building platforms, observed during a previous excavation seem to be platforms for outbuildings. The main building was previously dated to the late 3rd and 4th centuries but the outbuildings may be earlier than this. The remains of roof tiles and building blocks found near one of the outbuildings suggests that this was quite substantial but there is no evidence on how it was constructed. To quote directly: “All the evidence points to the 4th century as the period of most intensive occupation.”
There were a few fragments of worn, late first century or early 2nd century samian ware but the excavators think that this may have come from rubbish brought to the site. On the whole the evidence suggests that the building was a farmhouse associated with pastoral activity.
Dearne, M. J., Anderson, S. and Branigan, K. () Excavations at Brough Field, Carsington, 1980. DAJ v115 1995 037-075
This paper is about excavations at site A at Scow Brook, just south of Carsington and now under Carsington Reservoir. Two 4th century pigs of lead were recovered from a pit immediately north of site A in 1983. The pigs are uninscribed and dated from the context in which they were found. (Now in Buxton Museum)
Site A is a five acre site that has been extensively damaged by deep ploughing. The archaeologists excavated the part of the site where fieldwalking had produced high densities of pottery and building material. They mechanically stripped 0.6 acres and manually cleaned this area, known as Brough Field, SK 2452/2552. The area lay to the north-west of Scow Brook.
Phase 1 in the development of the site was a substantial rectangular timber building with ditches taking water away from the building.
Phase 2. By the end of the 2nd century the timber building had been superseded by buildings with stone foundations. Much stone had been removed from the site but there was enough left to infer three stone structures. The buildings seem to be connected to lead working. Pits contained galena (lead ore) and fragments of millstones, probably used for grinding ore.
Phase 3. The building fell into disuse and ditches were dug across the site.
The damage to the site made it difficult to establish a chronology. There were some sherds of pottery from the late 1st century/early 2nd century but overall phase 1 appears to be later. The buildings of phase 2 were constructed between 150 and 200. Only one coin was found, It was from AD139 but very worn so had probably been lost sometime after this date. Strangely, after the dig had completed, around 30 coins were reported as having come from the site. These had been found by fieldwalking and metal detecting. There were two very early coins from 71 BC and 32 BC. This simply demonstrates that Roman coins could remain in circulation for a long time before being deposited. There were five coins from the reign of Domitian, dated to around 90 to 94. Further coins were dated right through until the late 4th century and there were many that were too worn to date accurately. The archaeologists concluded that “An earlier second- or even late first-century origin for the site must be a possibility”.
To be convinced that Carsington is Lutudarum I would want to see more archaeology from the 70s and 80s.
Appendix 2 – Summary of the Romano-British Sites in the Lead Mining Area (from Lane (1986))
Crich. Possible Roman building and several Roman coins found but these were badly corroded. Two that were legible were 3rd century
Starkholmes. Early mine workings thought to be Roman but not possible to confirm the findings.
Darley Dale (Oker Hill). Some evidence of open cast working and lead ore deposits. Some 3rd century coins found and a Roman cremation.
Great Longstone. Brass pins and Roman coins found.
Castleton (Odin Mine). Traditions of Roman lead mining but no evidence. A pig of lead was found near Castleton but the exact location is unknown.
Wirksworth. Became an important lead mining administrative centre in the Saxon era but there is very little evidence of Roman activity. A few finds but no known Roman buildings.
Cromford. Although this would be ideally situated to monitor river traffic coming down the Derwent, there is not much evidence of Roman activity. Two pigs of lead were found in St. Marys churchyard (although some think that the find site may have been St. Mark’s churchyard)
Rainster Rocks (Nr Brassington). Excavated by Lane in 1970. Substantial occupation from around 180 to the mid 5th century, with most activity in the 3rd and 4th centuries. Evidence of lead smelting
The Boroughs, Wetton
Carsington. Three sites – Owslow Farm, Site A (Borough Field) and Site B (see Appendix 1)
Bradwell. A cyst burial found in 1897 could have been Roman. A hoard of 18 Roman coins was found at Hadfield’s Quarry, Pindale. Most have been lost and the one survivor is probably 4th century.
Nether Haddon. A gritstone Roman altar found at Haddon Hall
Eyam. Two Roman cremation urns found in the early 19th century. Maybe 3rd/4th century
Chee Tor. A series of enclosures. Pottery evidence for one of the enclosures gave a construction date of 3rd to 4th century.
Middleton by Wirksworth. Enclosures very close to lead mining activity. Derbyshire ware pottery suggests a Roman date for the lead working.
Smerrill Grange. Rectangular structures with surface finds of 3rd to 4th century Roman pottery
Scarcliffe Park. This has dating evidence earlier than most of the other sites in this list (end of 1st century/beginning of 2nd century) and also has significant evidence of lead smelting
Peakpits Brook, Alderwasley. 2nd to 3rd century pottery and lead slag.
Great Wilne. Large quantities of roofing tiles, box tiles and Roman pottery from late 1st to 4th century. Situated at confluence of the Derwent and the Trent. Possible site of Lutudarum, the etymology of the word meaning muddy water
Most of the information has come from Lane (1986) The Romans in Derbyshire.
The information about inscriptions on the pigs of lead is from the website, Roman Inscriptions of Britain, https://romaninscriptionsofbritain.org/inscriptions , although some of the pigs listed do not have inscriptions and the information comes from Lane.
The Derbyshire Archaeological Journal has relevant archaeological reports.
Patterson (2016) Roman Derbyshire
Ratledge, D. (2021) Derbyshire Archaeological Journal 141 7-31 (Route of the Buxton to Derby Roman road)
In May 1940 Germany invaded France. British troops in France retreated to the channel coast and most of the British Army was evacuated from Dunkirk but left most of their equipment behind. France quickly surrendered and there was a real danger that Britain would be the next target for invasion. General Ironside was given the responsibility of organising Britain’s defences. The first line of defence was along the coast but further inland a series of stop lines was envisaged that could halt the German advance if they broke through the coastal defences. These stop lines consisted of natural barriers and constructed defences. One stop line ran along the Thames upstream from London and along the Avon upstream from Bristol. Unfortunately, there is a gap between the two rivers and this gap was plugged by a defensive line (GHQ stop line red) running from Great Somerford on the Avon to Lechlade on the Thames, then further on to Tilehurst near Reading. Part of this gap was defended by an anti-tank ditch and pillboxes. The anti-tank ditch ran from just north of Wootton Bassett to the River Ray at Mouldon Hill in Swindon. Additional defensive support was provided by seven pillboxes along the route with an additional pillbox situated just north of Blunsden station.
Fig 1 Pillbox, north of Lydiard Millicent, west of Manor Hill Farm
Fortunately, the defensive line was never tested and after the war the ditch was filled in. Of course, the material from the ditch didn’t go back in completely and there was a hump where the ditch had been. Most landowners waited for the hump to settle but some spread the hump out to make the ground flat. The hump can still be seen in many places along the route but in some places the line of the ditch is marked by a slight dip where the hump was bulldozed and settling occurred afterwards. Pillboxes had been constructed to withstand direct hits from tanks so were extremely difficult to demolish, so most were simply left alone.
The route has been studied before and around 2000 two complementary articles were published, one in the Lydiard 2000 magazine by Michael Saunders and one in the Purton Historical Society by Eric Tull. The article by Eric Tull had a map of the route. I wanted to see if there are still any visible remains of the ditch today (2023). Before starting out in the field I examined LIDAR images of the area. LIDAR provides an accurate image of the ground surface by surveying from a light aeroplane. The big advantage of LIDAR is that an image can be produced of the ground surface without vegetation so that it often reveals features that are not visible to the naked eye. LIDAR images are readily available from lidarfinder.com but I used images that used DEFRA data downloaded to ArcGIS. DEFRA is a government agency that originally used LIDAR data to assess flood risks but is now available for most of the country. ArcGIS is a software package for processing and displaying geographical information.
Some sections of the ditch show very clearly on LIDAR
Fig 2 In this LIDAR image the ditch starts in the bottom left hand corner and heads north-east, crossing the Flaxlands road, going through the stable yard before skirting Frith’s copse.
From the LIDAR images I was able to construct these maps of the route:
Fig 3 Route of the ditch from LIDAR images (Southern section)
Figs 4 Route of the ditch seen by LIDAR (Northern section)
However, there were some areas where the route of the ditch wasn’t clear. But another source of data has recently become readily available. The National Library of Scotland publish several different versions of Ordnance Survey maps on their website, maps.nls.uk , not just for Scotland but for the whole of the UK. Recently that have also published aerial photographs, joined together to form a continuous picture. Currently they cover mainly the south east of England. The aerial photographs were mainly taken just after WW2 when the RAF had surplus planes and surplus pilots. For the area we are interested in the photographs appear to have been taken after the ditch was filled in but it is still very visible.
Fig 5. Aerial photograph from the post-war period. The ditch showing in the area north of Lydiard Millicent. Pillboxes show as white spots. In the top right hand corner the ditch touches the edge of the cricket ground
The aerial photographs can now be used to complete the map of the route of the ditch.
Fig 6 Route of the Ditch (Red line) and position of pillboxes (Purple dots)
Update Oct 2023. Since I first published this blog more aerial photographs have been made available on the Historic England website and those taken by the USAF in 1943 have shown that, at the south west end of the ditch it continued to the railway line to about the same place as the M4 crosses it now. The M4 building work obliterated the last section of the ditch. The complete picture now looks like this:
So what can we see today? Obviously, the pillboxes are the most visible remains but there also remains where the ditch crossed a road. Rather than dig up the road, a roadblock was created using concrete blocks and after the war these blocks were simply pushed to the side of the road, where amazingly many still remain. These are near The Fox:
Fig 7 Concrete blocks used as anti-tank measures
And there are four on the ramp leading up to Bremhill Bridge:
Fig 8 One of the concrete blocks used as a roadblock on the approach to Bremhill Bridge
But, what of the ditch itself? This photograph was taken from Flaxlands Lane looking south and the hump of the ditch can be clearly seen in the foreground.
Fig 9. The hump of the filled in ditch near Flaxlands Lane
Other places where the hump can be clearly seen are at the bottom of Flaxlands Lane in the field below Flaxlands Farm where the line of the ditch runs parallel to the road, and in Mill House field between Stone Lane and Purton where the line of the ditch runs diagonally across the field.
The archaeological remains of GHQ Stop Line Red are an important reminder of the impact of WW2 on a quiet corner of North Wiltshire. There are other reminders and these will be explored in future Blog posts.
Keith Allsop March 2023
Further Reading:
Wills, H (1985) Pillboxes, A Study of UK Defences 1940. Leo Cooper/ Secker and Warburg, London
Additional Information about the Pillboxes and other sites in Lydiard Millicent.
In June 1940 there was a real danger Britain would be invaded by Nazi Germany. France had fallen and while most of the British army had escaped via Dunkirk they had left their armour behind so Britain was vulnerable. Defences had to be constructed – and quickly.
The first line of defence was along the coast but if these defences were breached there were several stop lines further inland. One of these stop lines was GHQ stop line red which was designed to protect the industrial Midlands from an invasion on the south coast. The stop lines used natural barriers where possible and it was thought that the Thames would provide a barrier as far west as Reading, and the Avon would provide a barrier as far east as Great Somerford. The gap in the middle was closed by GHQ stop line red. This is the line that runs through Lydiard Millicent and in this area it consisted of an anti-tank ditch and pillboxes. The red line is the route of the anti-tank ditch and the purple dots are the pillboxes.
But Lydiard Millicent was impacted by the war in other ways. An ambulance depot was stationed at Lydiard House (The house in Lydiard Green not Lydiard House in Lydiard Park) and they picked up wounded forces personnel from the airfield at Down Ampney and transported them to the American hospital at Lydiard Park and other specialist hospitals further afield. In 1944 the American hospital became a hospital for German POWs, then after the war was used as temporary accommodation and at least one local resident was born there. Not far from the ambulance depot there was an Italian POW camp on the land that is now The Beeches and if you walk the footpath to the west of the Beeches you can still see the concrete bases of the huts that housed the prisoners.
The anti-tank ditch was filled in after the war so is difficult to see in this area but the pillboxes survive. They were built to withstand a direct hit from a tank shell so are difficult to demolish. There are two types on the Green; the one nearest the road would be manned by soldiers with Bren guns but the other two would also have a two pound anti-tank gun aiming towards German tanks coming from the south and south east.
The pillbox nearest the road is a type 22 which is a regular hexagon which would be manned by five soldiers with light machine guns (usually Bren guns). The entrance is at the rear, facing the road but this has now been blocked up.
The two pillboxes not visible from the road are type 28, designed to house a two pound anti-tank gun. This would be wheeled into position through the back of the pillbox with the barrel pointing towards the anti-tank ditch. Soldiers with bren guns would be able to fire at oncoming troops through the three smaller embrasures.
I have had a ground source heat pump for the last 15 years. In 2019 we had an extension built and added an air source heat pump to the system. This article is an objective view of the pros and cons of heat pumps from somebody with practical experience.
Heat pumps are supposed to be an efficient, renewable energy source. Is this true? They are expensive and take up much more space than, say, a gas combi boiler. Since 2021 new installations of heat pumps have been eligible for a grant of £5,000. Prior to this those who installed a heat pump in their home received a quarterly payment as they used the system; this payment was called the Renewable Heat incentive.
One of the most obvious disadvantages of a heat pump is the amount of space they take up. If you use a heat pump for room heating and hot water you need two tanks – one for the hot water and one for room heating. Add in the heat pump itself and it becomes impractical to house this inside most modern houses. The installation pictured is for a large four bedroomed house so would be smaller for a smaller house but still difficult to fit in. Most installations are therefore moved out to the garage. We now have two elements that combine to reduce the efficiency of the system.
Ground Source heat pumps are supposed to generate 4kW of output for every kW of energy input. For air source heat pumps this ratio is slightly less at 3:1. But as the water is stored it loses heat. As the water is transferred from the heat pump around the house it loses more heat. And since the heat pump is often situated away from the core of the house it is usually necessary to circulate the water around the house so that hot water arrives at the tap, but constantly circulating the water loses even more heat. I estimate that the true efficiency of the total system, including ground source heat pump, is around 1.75:1 and the air source heat pump around 1.5:1.
One of the features of a heat pump is that it does not heat the water as hot as a traditional gas boiler. For hot water heating a gas boiler is usually set to around 60°C. A heat pump is usually set to 50°C. The hotter you want the water the less efficient the heat pump becomes. The factory settings for my heat pump had a set temperature of 50° with a temperature drop of 10°. So, the heat pump heated the water to 50° then switched off. The water temperature would drop to 40° before the heat pump kicked in again. If you are unlucky when you run your bath the water is just above 40°. So, if you like a hot bath – tough. To help maintain a higher temperature I have changed the set points so that the set temp is now 51° and it drops to 43°before heating up again. These changes will have reduced the efficiency of the heat pump but make the water temperature a bit more acceptable.
The water for room heating is also lower. With underfloor heating the set temperature is usually around 35 – 40°. This usually varies with outside temperature. If it gets colder outside the set point increases so the water going through the underfloor heating is hotter. If the underfloor heating is running all the time and the room isn’t warm enough it is possible to increase the temperature of the water going to the underfloor heating. The trouble is, the higher the temperature, the less efficient it becomes. Underfloor heating is good for solid floors but not so good for suspended floors so the usual recommendation for upstairs rooms is low temperature radiators. These are larger than normal radiators and, like underfloor heating, are best left on a low temperature all the time. But this is very wasteful for bedrooms. Bedrooms are unoccupied most of the day and during the night you are snuggled up under a quilt so you only need heating for a short time in the evening and a short time in the morning. The best solution for this requirement is a traditional gas combi boiler with normal size radiators. If you don’t have gas, a short burst from an electric heater is better than having your heat pump, underfloor heating or upstairs radiators running all day.
The good thing about underfloor heating is that (sorry for stating the obvious) you don’t have any radiators so this gives more freedom when designing your rooms. Unfortunately, underfloor heating isn’t reactive. It gives a low heat all the time but can’t give heat quickly. So, if you were out at work all day you couldn’t come home and switch on the underfloor heating and expect it to warm up quickly; you would reach temperature in time for the ten o’clock news. However, the underfloor heating/heat pump system is ideal for homes where the house is occupied most of the time, eg for elderly people.
If you think that a heat pump is the system for you, I would make the following recommendations:
Install in new builds only
Design so that the heat water is produced near the kitchen and bathrooms (to reduce heat losses in transfer)
Insulate all hot water pipes
The advice given by heat pump installers is to insulate the home properly before installation – make sure loft insulation is adequate, windows are double glazed and draught free, cavity wall is insulated. All this is true but it then makes it impossible to evaluate the impact of the heat pump. The suspicion is that most of the savings come from the improved insulation.
After you have done all that, you then have a problem with ventilation and condensation may become a problem. Extractor fans in kitchen and bathrooms are necessary but suck warm air out of the house so a heat recovery system should be considered. The problem is that these are very expensive and the payback time is about a hundred years. My solution to the excess moisture in the air is to run a dehumidifier, but then, of course, you are increasing your electricity usage and any savings are soon wiped out.
Finally, what about service and repairs? The number of heating engineers qualified to install and maintain and repair heat pumps is quite small and you don’t have much choice in your local area. If you have a heating engineer nearby they often only have one employee who specialises in maintaining and repairing heat pumps so if he is on holiday – tough. Your recourse then is to call out the manufacturers. The Worcester Bosch call out fee is over £400!
On a more positive note heat pumps don’t need much routine maintenance. They are not dangerous so no matter how badly you treat them you are not going to die of carbon monoxide poisoning. The only danger is that you will die of shock when you see your bills.
Ringsbury Camp is an Iron Age hillfort near Purton in Wiltshire. As far as I am aware it has never been excavated or surveyed, so we know very little about it. However, it is well preserved, and features not visible to the naked eye are visible on LIDAR images. It sits on a bed of Corallian limestone and this can be seen at the entrance in the south eastern corner of the hillfort.
The hillfort (red dot on the map) is easily accessed by a short walk from Purton. There is a footpath that skirts the southern perimeter of the hillfort, but there is no public access to the rest of the monument.
Hillforts come in all shapes and sizes and it is unlikely that all hillforts had the same function. One proposed function of hillforts is that they were concerned with the management of animals. Most hillforts were built in the period 800 – 400 BC and this period coincided with a climatic downturn with prolonged periods of colder and wetter weather, and hillforts could have been built to protect sheep from winter storms (see Climate Change and the Iron Age on this website, https://before1066.com/climate-change-and-the-iron-age/). There is evidence from the LIDAR image that Ringsbury Camp had other roles to play in the management of sheep.
To the north of the hillfort are two annexes; annexes are a common feature of Iron Age hillforts and are generally believed to be connected with stock management. There is access to each annex from the hillfort ditch via a gap in the outer bank. At these points of access, the ditch is frequently waterlogged.
Also on the LIDAR image near the north west entrance is an additional bank and ditch that extends from the western entrance to the first annex.
On the south side of the hillfort the public footpath runs along the top of the outer bank and has worn a groove in the bank.
Where the Mud Lane footpath joins the fort there is an accumulation of loose stone.
My (very rough) diagram shows the features a little more clearly.
My hypothesis is that sheep approached the hillfort from the east along Mud Lane. Where Mud Lane joins the hillfort the accumulation of loose stone indicates that the bank of the hillfort may have been faced with stone and this has collapsed thanks to the action of tree roots. The sheep went up the incline to the top of the outer bank and followed the footpath around to the western entrance. The action of the sheep has worn a groove in the top of the bank.
When the sheep got to the western entrance the sheep were sorted. Some went into the waterlogged section of ditch which could have been a sheep-wash. Some went through the sheep-wash and exited into the first annex and some exited into the second annex. There is also a route around to the first annex that avoids the sheep-wash. So why were they being sorted? There several possibilities:
Sorting the sick from the healthy
Sorting pregnant from the non-pregnant
Sorting by owner; if the sheep were marked in some way the flock could have sheep from several owners
Sorting by the quality of the wool; castrated rams produced the best wool
I am sure there are other reasons why the sheep would have been inspected and sorted, but it does seem that the sorting process is a good explanation for the observed landscape features.
A different LIDAR image , supplied by Phil Barrett, shoes some additional features not evident in the image above.
The larger, second annex appears to have a route around the hillfort to the eastern entrance. So, animals sorted into this annex could return safely to the interior of the fort. The theory that the enclosures on the north side are indeed annexes is confirmed by the 1744 Enclosure Map of Purton (a copy of which can be seen in Purton Museum).
This map clearly shows Great Ringsbury and Little Ringsbury with two entrances between them, so confirming the structure proposed from the LIDAR images.
There is other evidence that Ringsbury Camp is concerned with the management of sheep. The sheep probably spent time away from the hillfort and were brought to it for the processes described above. One possible location would be Purton Common. The road leading from Purton Common towards Ringsbury Camp is known as Hogg’s Lane. Today a hog is usually a word used for a pig but it is also a word for a one-year old sheep, Hogg’s Lane could be the route taken when the young sheep were being moved to the hillfort.
For more about climate change and the Iron Age go to https://before1066.com/climate-change-and-the-iron-age/ . This was my dissertation for the MSc in Applied Landscape Archaeology at Oxford Continuing Education Department.
I have recently (Nov 2023) identified additional features outside the hillfort although these marks could be made by circular cattle feeders that were moved about the fields.
To the north of the annex there are several circles clearly visible in green against a parched background, indicating the presence of the ditches which are a feature of Iron Age huts. The rest of the field and an adjacent field also show the possible presence of features but they aren’t quite as clear cut.
However these crop marks can also be created by agricultural activity and circular animal feeders could produce similar markings in aerial photographs. The site seems worthy of a geophysical survey.
Is there another one just like the other one?
Less than 1km to the west of Ringsbury Camp is Bagbury Farm , adjacent to Bagbury Lane. There is some evidence that another hillfort may be hiding in this area. The obvious clue is in the name; the suffix -bury means fortified place and is shared by many hillforts. The next clue comes from the route taken by Bagbury Lane. The lane curves around before shooting off at a right angle. It could be curving around the remains of a hillfort that are no longer visible. The third clue comes from the 1744 enclosure map of Purton. As seen above the map shows Ringsbury Camp complete with its annexes and is divided into Great Ringsbury and Little Ringsbury. On the 1744 map there are also two adjacent fields known as Great Bagbury and Little Bagbury, so this could indicate that there was once a hillfort with annexes in this area. And finally there is LIDAR and aerial photography which appears to show a curved ditch along what would be the southern edge of a hillfort slightly larger than Ringsbury Camp.
A copy of The 1744 Purton Enclosure Map is on display in Purton Museum but if you need more information on this map you may contact me using the website contact details
There is no doubt that Repton was an important place to the Mercians and was also the site where the Viking Great Army overwintered in 873-874. Repton is frequently mentioned as a place where Mercian kings granted charters and the churchyard at Repton contains several graves that are distinctively Scandinavian.
The site around the Church was excavated by the Biddles between 1974 and 1980. Their conclusion was that the church was part of a defensive D shaped enclosure that had housed the Great Army. A nearby mausoleum was excavated and found to contain the bones of at least 264 individuals and the Biddles postulated that these individuals were part of the Great Army. However, the initial radiocarbon dates did not support this with some individuals appearing to have died in the 8th century. Cat Jarman looked at the bones again and concluded that many of the individuals had consumed a mostly marine diet and this had distorted the radiocarbon dates (the marine reservoir effect). When she corrected the radiocarbon dates for this effect all the individuals now had a date of death that was compatible with death around 873/874.
The D shaped enclosure
In their recent book ‘The Viking Great Army and the Making of England’, Julian Richards and Dawn Hadley (2021) question some of the conclusions about the D-shaped enclosure. The archaeology is complicated by the presence of ditches belonging to the bailey of the 12th century castle and Richards and Hadley believe it is possible that the archaeology may have been misinterpreted. To clarify this the excavation archive would need to be studied. It is possible that there never was a D shaped enclosure.
Did those buried in the mausoleum really have a marine diet?
The Great Army had been in England since 865. Their known overwintering sites were not near the sea and there is no evidence that they brought in vast quantities of fish for the 5000 or so members of the Great Army to eat. They appear to have lived off the tribute brought to them or foraged for in the local area. However, according to Cat Jarman, the isotopic evidence is that many of those buried in the mausoleum did have a diet with a significant marine food content. This is based upon C13 content of bone collagen which turns over about every 10-15 years. After 8 years in England there wouldn’t be much evidence left of a marine diet and this is the result obtained from samples sent to the University of Utrecht. The results from five samples indicated a marine food content of around 10%. A larger number of samples were analysed by the Oxford Radiocarbon Accelerator Unit but the same five samples indicated a marine food content of between 15 and 28%. The authors felt that the Utrecht figures were less reliable than those from Oxford, and only used the Oxford C13 results to calculate percentage marine diet content and revised radiocarbon dates that took into account the marine reservoir effect. A number of assumptions were made in the calculation and these had a significant impact on the precision of the results.
The revised radiocarbon dates were impacted in two ways. The dates became less old and the dates became less precise. Take sample G529 for example. The original radiocarbon date was 670-770. Taking into account marine reservoir effect the dates become 690 to 939. The range of possible dates has changed from 100 years to 249 years so almost any measurements will now include the 873/874 dates. Simply by including the marine reservoir effect in the calculation, the hypothesis that all the bones relate to the overwintering of the Great Army is now possible. This is very poor use of science.
So, in summary, the evidence for a D shaped enclosure is not convincing and the evidence that all the people buried in the mausoleum belonged to the Great Army is also a bit shaky.
Madgwick et al (2019) used strontium (Sr), oxygen (O) and sulphur (S) isotopes to determine how far pigs had been transported before being consumed at Neolithic sites in Wessex. Strontium is the most reliable indicator of geographical location and depends upon underlying geology. Strontium is incorporated into tooth enamel in young animals and is then fixed for the rest of the animal’s life. The strontium isotope values of a few pigs from some sites showed that they were raised in areas of older rocks (not the chalk found in Wessex). The Sr isotope ratio of bioavailable strontium on the Wessex chalkland is around 0.708, but some pigs had a Sr isotope ratio much higher than this, up to 0.717. There are older rocks in the south of Britain; the Silurian rocks of south wales and the pre-Cambrian rocks of the Malvern Hills have a high ratio, but rocks with a Sr isotope ratio as high as 0.717 are only found in the north of Britain, in the Lake District or some areas of Scotland. This led Madgwick et al to suggest that animals may have been brought from Scotland to Durrington Walls.
In another paper published around the same time, the same group (Evans et al 2019) studied Sr ratios in cattle. They had concluded that some cattle may have been transported from Scotland, but they also raised the possibility that there could be sources of high strontium isotope ratios in the south of Britain that were so far undiscovered. This possibility was raised because other papers had found high strontium isotope ratios in animals and humans that were very unlikely to have been raised in Scotland. However this suggestion was not included in the paper on pigs.
One of the problems with the suggestions that animals were moved around 400 miles before being consumed is the impracticality. It is conceivable that cattle could have been driven along drove roads to get from Scotland to Wessex, but this would have been a journey of several weeks. The return journey would take the total journey into months. Pigs are even more difficult to transport. Pigs cannot be herded like cattle or sheep so driving pigs all that way is highly improbable. Live animals could have been transported by sea but that would be an extremely arduous coastal route that would still involve land transport at each end of the journey. The only other possibility for the transport of live animals is that they were moved by cart. (Is there any evidence for wheeled vehicles in the neolithic?) If they weren’t transported as live animals were they butchered in Scotland and the meat carried to Wessex? Again, unlikely. If the pig had been butchered in Scotland would they really have carried the head all the way to Wessex?
Madgewick et al have been criticised for publicising an unlikely conclusion. Barclay and Brophy (2020), pointed out that strontium isotope ratios up to 0.716 have been found in the Malverns and several places in Wales. Only two pigs out of 131 had ratios above this with a maximum of 0.7172.
Madgwick et al responded by emphasising that their study was a multi isotope study and the results from oxygen and sulphur isotope values support their claim that the pigs could have originated from Scotland. I am not convinced. Oxygen isotope values from pigs are difficult to relate to oxygen isotope values of groundwater and they do not attempt to do this, so cannot identify possible origins of individual pigs. All they can say is that there is a variety of values that must reflect a variety of sources. My biggest problem with this is that pigs are omnivores. They eat anything that is available and if they are fed food waste, how the food has been processed will affect the oxygen isotope values.
Similarly sulphur isotope values cannot be related to specific locations. Generally values are related to the proximity of the sea but the resolution is poor and there is no map that relates sulphur isotope values to location. Again, the authors say that the wide variety of values reflects a variety of origins for the pigs.
Conclusions
To quote directly from Madgwick et al (2019):
On the basis of current mapping data, it is not possible to define origins with confidence, even when using multi-isotope proxies.
Unfortunately, in their abstract they are not quite so cautious and talk about transport pigs “over vast distances”. In their conclusion, based on strontium isotopes, they say that “some of the pigs are likely to derive from Scotland.” I think it is fair to say that their mixed messaging invites criticism.
Overall, the transporting of pigs from Scotland is a very unlikely scenario. There is no doubt that the animals consumed at Stonehenge came from a variety of sources but they most likely came from different sources across southern Britain.
Evans, J., Parker Pearson, M., Madgwick, R., Sloane, H. and Albarella, U. (2019) Strontium and oxygen isotope evidence for the origin and movement of cattle at Late Neolithic Durrington Walls, UK. Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences 11:5181-5197
Recently a more accurate strontium isotope map of south west England has been published, https://the-past.com/news/redrawing-the-strontium-isotope-map-for-the-south-west/ This demonstrates that there are areas in the south west that have higher strontium isotope ratios and that the cattle and pigs found in the Stonehenge area probably came from local sources, not from Scotland, vindicating the above post.
Several typos in the fist few pages made me take an instant dislike to this book. If you are going to write a book on history you have to be accurate. As well as the typographical errors there are other simple errors. For example when she talks about the end of Alfred’s reign she says that the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle is quiet on the closing years of the tenth century. Unfortunately Alfred died at the end of the ninth century. The book was clearly an attempt to capitalise on the 1100th anniversary of Aethelflaed’s death. As the deadline loomed there was no time for proof reading.
The only new material in this book is the unfounded speculation so if you must read a book on Aethelflaed read ‘Aethelflaed, The Lady of the Mercians’ by Tim Clarkson.
To understand the context of this post please read The Danelaw in Derbyshire. This summarises the evidence for the Danelaw boundary in this area. Place name evidence suggests that south Derbyshire was part of the Danelaw and controlled by the Vikings but Staffordshire and north-west Derbyshire remained Anglo-Saxon. The River Dove was the Danelaw boundary up to the Henmore brook but the boundary then followed the Henmore from west to east,
The traditional game of Shrovetide football is played in Ashbourne every Shrove Tuesday and Ash Wednesday. There are two sides, uppards and downards; uppards are those born on the north side of the Henmore Brook and downards those born on the south side. The goals are about three miles apart at the mills of Clifton and Sturston, Clifton is downstream from Ashbourne and Sturston upstream. The number of players on each side is unlimited and the objective is to carry the ball to the opposing mill and bang the ball three times against the mill wheel. Play starts at 2pm each day and finishes at 10pm.
The division of the sides into uppards and downards clearly mirrors the division of Ashbourne in the Danelaw period. The uppards are the Anglo-Saxons and the downards are the Vikings. The aim of the uppards (Anglo-Saxons) is to score at Sturston mill. The placename Sturston is believed to be a hybrid name – a Viking personal name + tun which is Old English for settlement. So the Anglo-Saxons are attemting to score at the Viking mill. The downards (Vikings) are attempting to score at the Clifton mill which has a placename that is purely Anglo-Saxon.
The earliest reference to Shrovetide football at Ashbourne is from the 17th century but ball games have mentioned earlier in the historical record and it is possible that the game at Ashbourne is based upon rivalries that have existed since the 9th or 10th centuries.
Footnote:
Atherstone (Warwickshire) has a similar game played on Shrove Tuesday. The game there starts at 3pm and lasts until 5pm and the person who has the ball at 5pm is the winner. Originally the game was a contest between the Atherstone inhabitants of Warwickshire and those of Leicestershire. Atherstone sits on Watling Street which, according to the Anglo-Saxon chronicle, was the border of the Danelaw. The contest dates back to at least 1200 and like Ashbourne Shrovetide the Atherstone game looks as if it had its origins in the rivalry between Vikings and Anglo-Saxons with the Vikings of Leicestershire taking in the Anglo-Saxons of Warwickshire. So it looks as if Vikings and Anglo-Saxons settled their differences with a game of football rather than swords and shields.